Coles Miller Blog

Leaseholders win landmark right to manage ruling at UK Supreme Court

Written by Nick Leedham | Nov 16, 2026, 4:19:59 PM

‘A minor paperwork error should not prevent leaseholders from taking control of their building’.

That is the message from a landmark Supreme Court ruling that could make it easier for flat owners across England and Wales to exercise their Right to Manage.

The UK's highest court has ruled in favour of a group of London leaseholders whose attempt to take over the management of their building was challenged because they had failed to send one resident a formal invitation to participate.

The unanimous judgment, delivered on 27th August 2026, removes a significant technical obstacle that freeholders could previously rely on to challenge certain Right to Manage applications.

For leaseholders unhappy with how their building is managed, the decision offers welcome reassurance. But what does it mean in practice?

What happened in the Supreme Court case?

The case, Avon Freeholds Ltd v Cresta Court E RTM Company Ltd, involved leaseholders at Cresta Court, a block of 20 flats in Hanger Lane, west London.

The residents had formed a Right to Manage (RTM) company to take responsibility for managing their building.

However, during the application process, the company failed to send a formal Notice of Invitation to Participate to one qualifying leaseholder.

The resident's leasehold registration was still being processed by HM Land Registry, which complicated the position. Although she subsequently joined the RTM company and supported its application, the freeholder, Avon Freeholds Ltd, argued that the missing notice invalidated the entire claim.

The dispute eventually reached the Court of Appeal, which agreed with the freeholder.

The leaseholders challenged that decision in the Supreme Court - and won.

The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the failure to issue the invitation did not invalidate the RTM company's entitlement to take over management of the building.

Importantly, the omission had not caused prejudice to the resident, the freeholder or anyone else involved.

What is the Right to Manage?

The Right to Manage was introduced under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002.

It allows qualifying leaseholders to take over the management of their building through a dedicated RTM company, without having to purchase the freehold or prove that their landlord has done anything wrong.

Once the right has been acquired, leaseholders can take greater control over matters such as:

  • Building maintenance and repairs
  • Service charge budgets and expenditure
  • Appointment of managing agents
  • Cleaning and upkeep of communal areas
  • Buildings insurance arrangements
  • Day-to-day management decisions.

For residents concerned about rising service charges, poor maintenance or a lack of communication from their managing agent, this can be an attractive option.

However, taking over management also brings responsibilities. Leaseholders must ensure that the building is properly maintained, legal obligations are met, and appropriate financial arrangements are in place.

Why is the Supreme Court ruling so important?

The decision draws an important distinction between the legal requirements that determine whether leaseholders qualify for the Right to Manage, and the procedural steps involved in making their application.

Previously, a mistake involving a required invitation to participate could potentially undermine an otherwise qualifying claim.

The Supreme Court has now clarified that the particular notice failures considered in this case cannot be used by a freeholder to defeat the RTM company's underlying entitlement.

In other words, a qualifying group of leaseholders should not lose its right to manage simply because of the type of procedural omission that occurred at Cresta Court.

The judgment is significant because it reduces the opportunity for freeholders to rely on certain technical objections, rather than substantive eligibility issues, to resist an RTM application.

It could also give leaseholders greater confidence to pursue management of their buildings, knowing that a minor administrative oversight will not necessarily bring the entire process to an end.

Does this mean leaseholders can ignore the paperwork?

No. The Right to Manage process still involves important legal requirements, and these must be followed carefully.

The Supreme Court did not abolish the obligation to issue invitations to participate or comply with the relevant notice periods. Instead, it clarified the consequences of failing to meet those particular procedural requirements.

There are still circumstances in which non-compliance can result in legal action or an order requiring an RTM company to correct an error. The ruling also does not change the fundamental eligibility requirements for acquiring the Right to Manage.

Leaseholders must still establish that their building qualifies, that the RTM company has been properly formed and that the necessary level of leaseholder participation has been achieved.

Getting the process right from the outset remains the best way to avoid delays, disputes and additional expense.

Could you take over the management of your building?

If you own a leasehold flat and are dissatisfied with how your building is managed, you may be able to exercise the Right to Manage. You do not need to demonstrate poor management or wrongdoing by your freeholder.

However, not every building qualifies, and the application must satisfy the relevant statutory conditions.

Before proceeding, it is worth considering:

Is your building eligible?

The legislation sets out requirements concerning the type of building, its use and the qualifying leaseholders.

Do enough leaseholders support the application?

The RTM company must have the required level of qualifying leaseholder membership when the formal claim is made.

Are you ready to take on management responsibilities?

Running a building involves decisions about maintenance, budgets, insurance and contractors. Many RTM companies appoint a professional managing agent to handle day-to-day matters.

Have you obtained legal advice?

Specialist advice can help you establish eligibility, prepare the necessary documentation and understand how to respond if your freeholder challenges the claim.

What does the ruling mean for freeholders?

The judgment also provides important guidance for freeholders and managing agents.

While landlords retain the right to challenge an RTM claim on valid grounds, the Supreme Court has made clear that the particular procedural failures considered in this case cannot be used to defeat an otherwise qualifying claim.

Freeholders will therefore need to distinguish between genuine questions about legal entitlement and procedural omissions that do not invalidate the claim.

Seeking advice at an early stage can help prevent unnecessary disputes and clarify the rights and responsibilities of everyone involved.

How Coles Miller Solicitors can help

The Supreme Court's decision is an important development for leaseholders who want greater control over their buildings.

However, exercising the Right to Manage is still a significant undertaking. Understanding the legal requirements and preparing the application correctly can help avoid costly complications.

Whether you are considering forming an RTM company, need advice about your eligibility or are facing a challenge from your freeholder, Coles Miller Solicitors can help.

Our experienced Residential Leasehold Property law team can guide you through your options, explain your legal rights and provide practical advice tailored to your circumstances.

Want greater control over how your building is managed?

Contact Nick Leedham at Coles Miller Solicitors to discuss your Right to Manage options and find out how we can help.